Comparison of Apple's iPhone and Garmin's inReach: Features and Functionality

Comparison of Apple's iPhone and Garmin's inReach: Features and Functionality

In the realm of outdoor exploration, staying connected in remote areas is becoming increasingly important. Two popular devices that cater to this need are the iPhone's satellite messaging feature and the Garmin inReach. Let's delve into a comparative analysis of these two devices, focusing on durability, coverage, SOS functionality, battery life, use in extreme weather conditions, navigation, weather updates, location sharing, cost, and messaging capabilities.

| Feature | iPhone Satellite Messaging | Garmin inReach | |--------------------------|-----------------------------------------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------------------| | **Durability** | iPhones are generally less rugged; require cases for outdoor durability. | Purpose-built rugged devices designed for harsh outdoor use. | | **Coverage** | Uses global satellite networks (e.g., Globalstar for iPhone), but may have limitations in dense forests or deep valleys. | Uses Iridium satellite network, providing **truly global coverage**, including poles and remote areas. | | **SOS Functionality** | Free SOS emergency messaging via satellite integration; requires iOS 16.1+ and clear view of sky. | Dedicated SOS button; SOS activation through subscription with instant communication to 24/7 monitoring centers. | | **Battery Life** | Limited by typical smartphone battery; satellite use drains battery faster; no dedicated power-saving mode for satellite tasks. | Up to **600 hours on low power mode** (25 days), including ability to reverse-charge phone. | | **Use in Extreme Weather** | iPhones are not certified for extreme conditions; may fail in cold, wet, or rugged environments. | Designed and tested for extreme weather conditions (cold, wet, dust, shock). | | **Navigation** | Basic navigation via Maps and apps; limited offline topographic capabilities. | Integrated GPS with detailed topographic maps, route planning, and navigation support through apps. | | **Weather Updates** | Limited or no satellite-delivered weather updates; dependent on cellular/Wi-Fi for detailed forecasts. | Provides satellite-delivered weather forecasts with subscription. | | **Location Sharing** | Limited location sharing via Messages or Find My app; requires some network connection or satellite messaging feature. | Robust location sharing with tracking and breadcrumb trails via satellite connection. | | **Cost** | No additional subscription for SOS; satellite messaging plans may incur some cost depending on carrier and coverage conditions. | Subscription plans ranging roughly from **$8 to $50/month**, with different tiers offering messaging, tracking, weather, and SOS. Upfront device cost $300-$500+. | | **Messaging Capabilities**| Limited to basic short text messages via satellite link, mostly for emergency use. | Two-way messaging with larger message sizes, photo and voice memos supported on some models. More flexible and user-friendly interfaces. |

The Garmin inReach stands out for true rugged durability, comprehensive global coverage via the Iridium network, superior battery life, advanced navigation, and dedicated satellite weather updates. It is a specialized device optimized for backcountry reliability, including a well-established SOS system with monitoring.

On the other hand, the iPhone satellite messaging offers convenient SOS functionality without extra hardware or subscription cost. However, its battery, durability, and satellite messaging features are more limited. It may be suitable for casual or occasional backcountry users when paired with protective cases but is not a replacement for a purpose-built satellite communicator like Garmin inReach in serious or extreme conditions.

In terms of cost, Garmin requires upfront device purchase plus subscription fees, while iPhone uses built-in hardware with minimal to no satellite usage fees, but less capability overall.

Backcountry adventurers requiring robust, reliable, and fully featured satellite communication and navigation should prefer Garmin inReach, while iPhone satellite messaging is a valuable emergency backup and convenience feature for more casual use.

[1] Garmin (2021) Garmin inReach Explorer+: Global Satellite Communicator with GPS Navigation and Two-Way Messaging. [Online] Available at: https://www.garmin.com/en-GB/products/handhelds/inreach-explorer-plus/

[2] Apple (2022) Emergency SOS via satellite. [Online] Available at: https://support.apple.com/en-gb/iphone/emergency-sos-via-satellite

[3] The Verge (2022) iPhone 14's satellite connection is a life-saving tool, but it's not a replacement for a dedicated satellite communicator. [Online] Available at: https://www.theverge.com/22718763/iphone-14-emergency-satellite-connection-review-garmin-inreach-spot

1. The Garmin inReach offers superior durability, global coverage, extended battery life, advanced navigation, and dedicated weather updates, making it an ideal choice for backcountry adventurers who require robust, reliable, and fully-featured satellite communication and navigation.
2. While the iPhone satellite messaging provides convenient SOS functionality without additional hardware or subscription costs, its battery, durability, and satellite messaging features are relatively limited compared to the Garmin inReach.
3. Garmin inReach requires upfront device purchase and subscription fees, while the iPhone utilizes built-in hardware with minimal to no satellite usage fees, but offers less capability overall.
4. For casual or occasional backcountry users, the iPhone satellite messaging may serve as a valuable emergency backup and convenience feature, but it cannot replace a purpose-built satellite communicator like the Garmin inReach in serious or extreme conditions.

Read also: