Which option offers a greater environmental friendliness, higher cost, and superior performance between Firework Displays and Drone Shows? - Comparing costs, environmental impact, and performance, which one takes the lead between fireworks and drone shows: the eco-friendly drone show or the traditional fireworks?
In the summer season, the controversial topic of fireworks arises, particularly during festivals like Mainz's Johannisnacht and "Rhein in Flammen". As environmental concerns intensify, many are questioning whether drones or light shows, especially under drought conditions, would be a more suitable alternative for these events, including smaller folk festivals.
The tradition of fireworks may be relinquished this year at the Johannisnacht, with a music-accompanied drone show taking its place. The cost, however, is approximately doubled compared to traditional fireworks. "Rhein in Flammen", on the other hand, has opted for an addition: a drone show, in addition to the traditional fireworks in Koblenz. The BUND (Bund für Umwelt und Naturschutz Deutschland) also presses for a renunciation at the Schiersteiner Hafenfest in Wiesbaden, given its sensitive location adjacent to an EU bird protection area and a nature reserve. In contrast, a fireworks display with music is planned for the conclusion of the Frankfurt Museum Embankment Festival.
The BUND Rhineland-Palatinate warns of the fire risk posed by fireworks due to the ongoing drought, which may lead to canceled displays this year. Fireworks also produce waste and toxic substances such as perchlorate, contributing to soil, water, and air pollution. The fireworks industry, however, argues that the substances are water-soluble and only a concern "for about ten minutes once a year."
"The fireworks themselves are relatively weather-independent," says "Rhein in Flammen" GmbH. Ultimately, the organizer decides on the implementation of the ship convoy and fireworks, always in close coordination with participating security organizations like the police and fire department.
Fireworks pose a significant threat to wildlife, especially during the breeding season. They cause birds and mammals to flee in panic, potentially leading to injuries and abandonment of nests. Fireworks also frighten pets like dogs and cats.
Drones and light shows, on the other hand, necessitate a substantial budget. "The fireworks are cheaper," admits "Rhein in Flammen" GmbH. Thomas Fischer, managing director of Beisel Pyrotechnik, states that the budget is the primary challenge. Fischer's company organizes around 100 fireworks displays annually.
Smaller drone shows can start at around $15,000, with medium-sized shows costing closer to $40,000. Larger displays can exceed $500,000 depending on the number of drones used, complexity, and location. For a more intimate or simpler display, drone shows may be more cost-effective for smaller festivals and events. However, as scale and complexity increase, drone shows can become comparable to or more expensive than traditional fireworks displays.
Drones also suffer from wind and rain, potentially impacting their performance. Their production process is not environmentally friendly. However, the Koblenz city council faction of the Greens views drone shows as a more sustainable alternative due to fewer safety concerns and reduced noise and fine dust pollution.
For an impressive show, a combination of drones and fireworks could be the magic solution. Drones could display symbols, logos, and messages, while fireworks provide the magic of fire and sound of rockets. However, not all cities may have the necessary backdrop for a captivating light show.
In summary, the cost comparison between drone shows and fireworks for smaller festivals and events can vary significantly based on several factors. For smaller events, drones might be more affordable, but for larger or more complex displays, both options can be similarly priced or higher depending on the specifics of the event. The eco-friendly nature and potential for reuse of drone equipment can also reduce long-term costs for frequent users. The decision between the two ultimately depends on the event's budget, complexity, and environmental concerns.
The BUND Rhineland-Palatinate suggests that the Schiersteiner Hafenfest in Wiesbaden should consider a change from traditional fireworks to drone shows or light shows, given the sensitive location of the festival. The appeal of a combination of drones and fireworks for an impressive show raises questions about the eco-friendly benefits of each option and their suitability for various events and budgets, particularly smaller festivals.
